Rachel Kushner's"Creation Lake" is this season's literary lightning rod, drawing extreme critical reactions.
The 55-year-old Kushner's new novel, long-listed for the Booker Prize, received extravagant praise Sunday from The New York Times' Dwight Garner in the newspaper's Sunday Book Review, and condemnation from American novelist Brandon Taylor in the current London Review of Books.
While Taylor questioned why the novel was even written and joked in an X feed that the book "gave him Lyme Disease," Garner in his review said the book "consolidates Kushner's status as one of the finest novelists working in the English language. You know from this book's opening paragraphs that you are in the hands of a major writer, one who processes experience on a deep level. Kushner has a gift for almost effortless intellectual penetration."
Washington Post reviewer Ron Charles agreed with Garner, gushing that "Creation Lake" "bears all the hallmarks of her inquisitive mind and creative daring." In an expansive review in the Atlantic, Lily Meyer called the book a "swerve" that "suggests Kushner is ready for big change."
While the Guardian lauded the book, the Wall Street Journal reviewer Sam Sacks was lukewarm, relegating "Creation Lake" to his fiction roundup in the WSJ's Saturday Review.
Garner's review likely will do more than any other to boost the book's sales. Garner is the Times' most important book critic, now mainly writing for the Sunday newspaper rather than the daily Arts section, and the Sunday Book Review is the nation's leading literary arbiter.
Kushner's novels "The Flamethrowers," "Telex from Cuba" and "The Mars Room" also stirred heated critical debate, as did her essay collection "The Hard Crowd."
It'll be interesting to see if "Creation Lake" lands on the Times' best-seller list after garnering such media attention. These days, fantasy, horror and romance novels dominate the list, rarely crashed by "literary novels."