Following Tiger Woods' inability to mount any kind of charge in the Players Championship, the golf buzzards are wondering whether he's lost his swing. Hey, fly back to your leather-winged nests. He shot 73 the final day and was five under for the tournament, hardly horrible golf. Yes, he fell short at the Masters too, but he still made some noise when paired with Phil Mickelson the final day. At the Players Championship, Mickelsen finished way back, but the critics aren't claiming he's finished. Are they?
With that said, a few of Woods' swings, especially early in the final round, were curious. At the first hole, he almost shanked his approach, bringing a loud outcry from Johnny Miller. He kept showing that same tendency to not get through his shot, pushing it to the right. Plus, since he's come back from his knee injury, he's not displaying his old astounding distance, from tee shots to approaches. Mickelsen constantly outdrove him at Augusta National. Woods' old astonishing power and precision have faded away. He says the knee is fine, but is he unconsiously favoring it? As with NFL quarterbacks, perhaps he'll need some more time to show his old excellence.
In the middle part of Jack Nicklaus' career, say around 1975, he also started showing that shank swing, pushing the ball to the right. Nicklaus adjusted and went on to a number of years of championships. Nicklaus, losing some distance, also had to sharpen his short game. Before, he was so far ahead of everyone else on his long game and putting that he didn't have to have a topflight short game, but he developed one.
Woods has always had an oustanding short game, so he should continue as the top player in the world for many years to come, if he can fix that bad swing tendency of hitting it to the right. The same happens with baseball players. As the years go by, pitchers find they can get hitters out by throwing low and outside. The best hitters adjust and continue hitting the outside pitch. If not, their average and power drops. I'm confident that Woods will make the adjustment. He's already re-invented his swing more times than any other great player in the history of the game.
Meanwhile, the Players Championship suffered a lack of drama, such as affected the Masters in 2008. The lack of wind made the 17th hole less of an adventure, although a few players, Mickelsen included, found the water. With the tournament now played in early May, the winds will likely remain quiet in the future. Henrik Stenson grabbed hold of the tournament halfway through the final day as everyone else was collapsing on the fast, dried out course. Stenson, who has perpetually shown up on the leader board at big tournaments for years, showed strong shot-making ability and strategic command to capture his most significant victory yet. And, thankfully, he kept his clothes on, although some fans of the handsome Swede might have been disappointed.
The Players Championship apparently has given up its effort to gain status as the fifth major, although NBC's crew treats it like it is. They consciously pick up some of the mannerisms of CBS' coverage of the Masters, such as those flower shots, although thankfully, they are less reverential. In fact, the rowdiness of the fans lounging on the big slope besides the island green makes the Players the anti-Masters. I'm all for the game's traditions of sportsmanship and restraint, but the scene at 17 gives the Players its own intensity. The U.S and British Opens have a tradition of rabid fans, which add to their appeal. Of course, the Masters' fans are known for their cheers and yells. But the hushed tones and false piety of the CBS crew at Augusta grow old.
Actually, I thought NBC did a better job with the Players than CBS did with the Masters. Unlike CBS, NBC didn't go ga-ga over Woods, and didn't seem to miss as many shots. The candid commentary of Miller probably wouldn't be acceptable to the Tories of Augusta National, but he's always funny and refreshing, if sometimes too obvious. All in all, a good job, although Bob Murphy can make some pretty lame observations, such as the time someone pulled a ball in a trap and he commented "That's a bad shot."
The Players, I suppose, is the leader of a second level of near-major tournaments such as Jack Nicklaus' Memorial and Arnold Palmer's Bay Hill Classic and perhaps one or two more. Yet its stature, with its strong field and distinctive course, makes it stand above these. So, it exists in a realm of its own, better than all other tournaments but not quite a major. Perhaps it could grow into an undeniable major if it were rotated to different championship courses. I'd love to see it played at Doral, with Doral toughened up to make it live up to its old "Blue Monster" nickname. However, as with Augusta National and the Masters, the TPC championship course is the Player's signature. But I would love to see more of America's great courses, without having to wait for them to roll around for the U.S. Open and PGA. Now, like the Masters, usually played on Easter, and the U.S. Open, played on Father's Day, the Players will have its own holiday - Mother's Day. Perhaps that'll add to its majors charisma.
In regard to the 17th, the island hole, I have my doubts about it as a championship test. Luck should play a part in golf, but the 17th often is too arbitrarily cruel. I saw one player Sunday hit his tee-shot about three feet from the hole, and the ball bounced into the water. The celebrated 12th hole at Augusta also is often played into the wind, but a player at the Masters will be rewarded for a shot close to the hole. Sure, a ball can roll from the front of the green back into Rae's Creek at Augusta's 12th, but that is penalizing a bad shot. Plus, Augusta National's No. 12 has a bunch of landing space behind the green, giving a player an opportunity to recover with his short game if he hits a long shot. Such an option doesn't exist at the Stadium Course's 17th. You're just in the water, and hitting from the drop zone.
Moving the Players to May has given it a different dimension. When it was played in March, the course was lush, with devilish spring winds making the 17th a nightmare for the players and a joy for spectators, on the course and at TV. The tournament signaled an end to the winter tour and was a fitting end to the great run of Florida tournaments at Doral and Bay Hill. Now, though, with May's drier conditions, heat, and lack of wind, it looked like the beginning of the summer season, the prelude to the U.S. Open.
No More Baby: When will Celtics forward Glen Davis lose his nickname, Big Baby? The former LSU star has been mainly outstanding throughout the playoffs, and hit the game-winning shot with time running out to give the Celtics a series tie with the Orlando Magic. When he was a chubby, ebullient player in college, the name fit. Then, he had a tough time adjusting to the NBA, often looking like a child in a man's game. At times, he appeared totally in deep water, that he would never be more than a marginal player. But now, he's developed a trim body and lost his baby fat and shown the competive steel he always showed in college despite his gentle, comic spirit. Stepping into the shoes of the injured Kevin Garnett, he's proved his mettle. Big Baby is a great nickname, and he'll probably trade it in for endorsement ties if the Celtics continue their success. But he's outgrown it. Now, he's an adult in the NBA.